Monday, September 28, 2009
Fairview Golf Course manager and PGA golf pro Mike Habermehl heads back to the clubhouse Friday afternoon as he moves items to a temporary pro shop before construction begins on the aged building. Mr. Habermehl is in the process of negotiating a new contract with the city.
A golfer's anger flies in as many directions as a poorly struck 3-iron.
A putt that won't break brings gasps to the green. A slice with the driver triggers a tirade on the tee. And a rumor about the golf pro's job security brings madness to the microphone at City Hall.
Mike Habermehl has spent the past 24 years as PGA golf pro and manager at Fairview Golf Course. His performance recently earned him recognition as the PGA's Midwest Section Professional of the Year.
Despite the honor, uncertainty clouds Mr. Habermehl's future at Fairview as he negotiates with the city for a new contract.
The City Council's Parks & Recreation Committee will hold a meeting at 6 p.m. Tuesday in the council chamber at City Hall to discuss the matter.
Before addressing the issue, Mr. Habermehl and Parks & Recreation Director Bill McKinney each want to quiet the most persistent rumor in the clubhouse: Mr. Habermehl has not been fired, terminated or asked to resign. He remains under contract through Dec. 31 and will perform all regular job duties until that date.
Local golfers have reason to worry, though. Mr. Habermehl said negotiations with the city are "at a standstill" as the two sides debate who should receive revenue from golf cart rentals, concessions and the driving range.
Mr. Habermehl currently receives the revenue from all three sources, along with a small salary of $250 per month. Mr. McKinney's proposal would direct all revenue to the city and give Mr. Habermehl a substantially higher salary that he declines to discuss, but that Mr. McKinney puts at $88,800 per year.
"I honestly don't think they're trying to run me off," Mr. Habermehl said. "I think the city of St. Joseph wants to make a business decision."
Mr. McKinney has prepared three pages of statistics defending the city's decision to reach for more revenue. One list shows the 2008 operating revenue and expenses for municipal golf courses in Maryville, Chillicothe, Savannah and Platte City. Fairview's revenue of $374,000 trails the closest competitor by almost $200,000, with two of the courses more than doubling Fairview's revenue. Fairview actually spent $14,000 more than it brought in, which forced Mr. McKinney to raid the parks department budget to subsidize the golf fund.
With additional revenue sources - which Mr. McKinney pledges to spend entirely on the course - Fairview could be on par economically with the other municipal courses in Northwest Missouri.
"I just wanted to do these comparisons to show that we're not crying wolf," Mr. McKinney said. "This is really happening."
If Mr. Habermehl leaves, Gary Cunningham, president of the men's club at Fairview, predicts many golfers will cancel their memberships and join nearby clubs such as Moila Country Club or Duncan Hills Golf Course in Savannah, Mo. Mr. Cunningham also expects several tournaments to search for a new site.
"The city is going to lose a lot more than what they think they're going to make," Mr. Cunningham said.
Mr. McKinney acknowledges that a few golfers may leave, but thinks a new golf pro would run the course well enough to avoid much of an immediate drop. Which brings up another rumor: that the city will place Penny Winguard from the maintenance staff in charge of the course and forgo hiring a new golf pro.
"We will have a golf pro and they will be PGA certified, no matter what," Mr. McKinney said. "Penny will be in charge of a lot of the paperwork over the revenue from carts and concessions and the range, but she isn't getting a raise. She won't be in over Mike or the next pro if Mike leaves. If anything, the pro will have more time to spend on golf - giving lessons and booking tournaments."
Aside from revenue, Mr. Habermehl worries about another item he would no longer control: personnel. He currently employs two full-time and three part-time workers at the course that he pays with revenue he generates at the course.
"I have a bit of a moral issue because they could lose their jobs," Mr. Habermehl said.
Mr. Habermehl insists he holds no ill will against Mr. McKinney. The parks director holds a similar view.
"I hope it works out so we can keep Mike here for a long time," Mr. McKinney said. "I don't always agree with every decision he makes, but I think Mike has done a good job."
Clinton Thomas can be reached at clintonthomas@npgco.com.
Clarification: A story on Page A1 of Monday's paper incorrectly stated that the city offered Mike Habermehl a salary of $88,800 to serve as golf pro at Fairview Golf Course. The city would pay Mr. Habermehl $30,000 to run tournaments and outings and an incentive worth $4,800 to acquire tournaments. The city's proposal also projects Mr. Habermehl will collect revenue from customers worth an estimated $54,000 for lessons, merchandise sales, club repair and the junior golf program, for a total contract value of $88,800.



Share Your Thoughts
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.
rk92559 says...
Oh what short memories we have. I played on Fairview when it was an absolute dump. When you could walk on for free because nobody was even in the clubhouse, and members would take it upon themselves to plant a tree or 2 on a dried out piece of crap course.It was Mike that organized it and put in the time and effort to make it what it is today. He is a true golf pro, and an excellent teacher. A class act from the time he arrived. Every effort should be made to retain him.
September 28, 2009 at 12:43 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
Memorii says...
This is the first I've heard of this. However, am I understanding it right that because he had a fit over something he did wrong on the course that he's now going to be replaced, rather than having his contract renewed?
Like I said, I don't know what's going on with this, this is the first I've heard of it. But, if that's the case, then I think it's silly to replace him over this. Everyone has times when they're so frustrated with their own performance when they know they should have done better and once in a while it gets the best of the person. Did he hurt anybody? If not, what's the problem?
If he's done such good for Fairview, then I think he should be asked to stay instead. One little instance of outburst shouldn't constitute getting rid of him.
I don't know, it seems kind of petty to me. But, then again, I might be totally misunderstanding the entire issue.
September 28, 2009 at 4:52 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
oldguy says...
Mike has done and continues to do an outstanding job. The reach for immediate revenue seems shortsighted when you think of long term revenue implications of replacing him with someone lacking everything he brings to the position
September 28, 2009 at 8:02 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
heritage_sarahhochschwender says...
i think you might be confused by the intro to the real story. i have talked to a few golfers who patronize the course, and by all accounts the pro is a genuine PRO.
what do most other municipal courses do? are there other independent contractor pros? will making this change really impact the membership, just as the no-smoking issue decimated the bingo hall? how much money has been poured into the nature center and taken from the museum funds in a questionable move by the administration?
sounds penny wise and pound foolish on the face of this discussion.
September 28, 2009 at 8:05 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
bigbob says...
A few questions beg for answers, If $88,000 isn't enough, how much is the pro getting from the concessions now? As to the other nearby courses, what fees do they charge compared to us? Does the pro set the fees? Why were there shortfalls one year? If you are going to report, please include "facts"
September 28, 2009 at 10:31 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
deerhaven says...
Mike is a class act he treats everyone with respect , he has built that cow pasture into a good golf course and with the city finally making some improvements it will get better. With all the crap that goes on in St. Joseph City government you would think they would want to show case there only public golf course in town but no they want to ruin what is left of a good thing to St. Joseph.
September 28, 2009 at 11:46 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
heritage_sarahhochschwender says...
perhaps the gentleman prefers the relative autonomy he enjoys with the current arrangement. certainly his concern for the employees is very admirable.
September 28, 2009 at 3:35 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
stjoeresident says...
Why is this being aired out in public on the front page.. really isn't there other issues to be focused on. Come on
September 28, 2009 at 6:49 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
XJotowner says...
The arrangement is similiar to that of a Country Club were the Pro makes his money from the carts, lessons, and pro shop sales. The only difference is Fairview isn't charging hundreds of dollars a month for memberships to pay for the maintence and upkeep of the grounds and buildings, I would believe the city is trying to do that from the greens fees.
In my personal experience the course is very average for a muni/public course and after the heat of summer the greens are about the only thing still green. it sounds like Mr. Mickinney is wanting to use some of the revenues from carts, pro shop sales, and driving range to enhance a potentially very nice course. I look forward to playing it in the spring or early summer when back visiting and with some upgrades it would be a destination course for golfers all around the Buchanan County area and beyond. Many golfers know what I mean. A lot of people drive to Mozingo in Maryville or Shoal Creek of Barry Road because of the quality of the courses, when I doubt many come that far to play Fairview.
September 28, 2009 at 8:42 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )